Reference Values for Indoor Air Problems Orders of Magnitude Less Than PEL's

Airborne Concentrations of Volatile Organic Compounds, Formaldehyde and Ammonia in Finnish Office Buildings with Suspected Indoor Air Problems
Authors: Heidi J. Salonen a; Anna-Liisa Pasanen b; Sanna K. Lappalainen a; Henri M. Riuttala a; Tapani M. Tuomi a; Pertti O. Pasanen c; Beatrice C. Bck a; Kari E. Reijula a
Affiliations: a Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, Helsinki, Finland
b Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, Kuopio, Finland
c Department of Environmental Science, University of Kuopio, Kuopio, Finland

Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Volume 6, Issue 3 March 2009 , pages 200 - 209
Abstract
A database of indoor air concentrations of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) (n = 528), formaldehyde (n = 76), and ammonia (n = 47) in office environments was analyzed to suggest interpretation guidelines for chemical measurements in office buildings with suspected indoor air problems. Indoor air samples were collected for VOCs from 176 office buildings, 23 offices for formaldehyde, and 14 office buildings for ammonia in 2001-2006. Although the buildings had reported indoor air complaints, a walk-through inspection by indoor air specialists showed no exceptional sources of indoor air pollutants. The measurements of chemical pollutants did not indicate any clear reason for the complaints. The geometric mean concentration of total volatile organic compounds (TVOC) was 88 μg m-3 in office rooms and 75 μg m-3 in the open plan offices. The mechanical supply and exhaust ventilation significantly (p <>The highest mean concentration and frequency distributions were determined for the individual VOCs. The most common VOCs found in ≥ 84% of the indoor samples include toluene, xylene (p,m), 1-butanol, nonanal, and benzene. According to concentrations, the most abundant VOCs were 2-(2-ethoxyethoxy)ethanol, acetic acid, 1,2-propanediol, and toluene. The geometric mean concentration of formaldehyde and ammonia in the office buildings was 11 μg m-3 (3-44 μg m-3 and 14 μg m-3 (1-49 μg m-3, respectively. On the basis of statistical analyses, the guideline value indicating a usual concentration of the pollutant in office buildings is 70 μg m-3 for TVOC, 7 μg m-3 for most individual VOCs, 10 μg m-3 for formaldehyde, and 12 μg m-3 for ammonia… The guidance value suggested for TVOC is 250 μg m-3, for formaldehyde 15 μg m-3, and for ammonia 25 μg m-3. If the guidance value is exceeded, this may indicate the existence of an exceptional source and the need for additional environmental investigations. The levels should not be used for the evaluation of health risks. The guideline values are applicable in a subarctic climate for modern, urban office buildings.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
BrooklynDodger(s) comments: The Dodger(s) appreciate(s) that these investigators are willing to put an index value on exposure levels associated with indoor air complaints, although the Dodger(s) see no clear rational for these values. Formaldehyde at .010 mg/m^3 is equivalent to 0.008 ppm, well below the ATSDR MRL for intermediate duration exposure of 0.03 ppm. An interesting account of an indoor air investigation at the National Center for Health Statistics can be found at

http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/hac/PHA/nationalcenter/nch_p1.html